A tea party @ Mrs. Claus Cafe in Yankee Candle with a few games and a craft. I would provide the game(s) and craft and would need to figure things out that could be done in a relatively small area ( possibly seated).
A craft party at Michael's with cake and drinks afterwards. Each girl would make and take home a craft and then have cake and drinks and open presents.
A sleepover party at our house that included dinner, a movie, some crafts, and makeovers.
An ice cream social party at our house where each child makes their own sundae. Have drinks and goodie bags and open presents afterwards.