It was absolutely fantastic!
I had it, and I loved it! When you make it again, let me know so I can have more!
I had it, and liked it. Please keep me in mind when you make more!
I had it, and it was okay. Not bad, but I wouldn't consider it my favorite dish.
Your effort and cooking were satisfactory, but it wasn't something I normally like to eat.
This wasn't your best dish: Try something else!
You pretty much suck at life: This is not a future for you.