If you were eating a bagel with cream cheese on it and I asked you if the cream cheese was good. Would you think I was crazy and berate me the rest of the morning?

If you are eating a bagel with cream cheese on it and I asked if the cream cheese was good. Would you find that question weird and berate me the rest of the morning?

If I noticed you eating a bagel with cream cheese on it and I ask if the cream cheese was good. Would you find that question strange?