Gabe Brkic (Ohio) - 3/4 field goals (42, 40, 37 yards), 9/9 kickoffs for touchbacks
Voters:
Cameron Dicker (Texas) - 2/2 field goals (53, 32 yards), 4/8 kickoffs for touchbacks, 40-yard average (2 punts, 1 inside 20-yard-line), 6/6 extra points
Voters:
Ryan Fitzgerald (Georgia) - 4/4 field goals (45, 43, 35, 31 yards), 42-yard punt average (6 punts, 4 inside 20-yard-line), 4/5 kickoffs for touchbacks
Voters:
David Fletcher (Illinois) - 4 touchdowns as QB (3 rushing, 1 passing), 45-yard punt, 9/9 extra points, 3 kickoffs for touchbacks
Voters:
Jake Moody (Michigan) - 4/4 field goals (55, 36, 37, 36, 33 yards), 8/8 kickoffs for touchbacks, 40-yard punt average (3 punts, 2 inside 20-yard-line), 2/2 extra points
Voters:
Ryan Sanborn (California) - 52-yard punt average (3 punts), threw successful 2-point conversion pass, 1/1 field goals (29 yards), 199 passing yards as QB, 48-yard rushing touchdown
Voters:
Matthew Trickett (Ohio) - 3/4 field goals (55, 45, 40), 48-yard punts average (3 punts), 6/7 kickoffs for touchbacks
Voters:
Joseph Zepp (Arizona) - 22-yard field goal, 47.3-yard punt average (4 punts)
Voters: